Bug report #739
GRASS Shell non-functional in OS X
|Affected QGIS version:||Regression?:||No|
|Operating System:||OS X||Easy fix?:||No|
|Pull Request or Patch supplied:||Resolution:||fixed|
|Crashes QGIS or corrupts data:||Copied to github as #:||10798|
The GRASS Shell impementation in OS X is non-functional. Oddly, trying to type in commands results in keyboard shortcuts being executed for qgis. For instance, trying to type v.in.ogr stops as soon as the v key is hit. The add vector layer dialog comes up.
I do not know if this is a qgis or qt problem. Perhaps there is a method to turn off keyboard shortcuts? If so, I would recommend having them off by default, or at least requiring some form of modifier like the option key.
This happens in 0.8.1 and 0.9.
#2 Updated by John Tull about 13 years ago
I tested the functionality of the GRASS shell with single-key shortcuts edited out of qgisapp.cpp (i.e., commented out "V", "N", ".", etc.) on OS X with the 0.9 source. Unfortunately, it is not so simple. The shell itself does not handle keyboard inputs properly, and there are also drawing/refresh problems (e.g., cursor disappears after sending a return keystroke).
I am changing this to a plugin defect rather than a gui defect.
#4 Updated by Tom Elwertowski almost 13 years ago
The initial shell prompt does not appear.
The shell subprocess dies at the first keystroke and the plugin doesn't notice.
Action keys are processed be qgis because the shell subprocess is no longer there.
The connectivity between the shell subprocess and the plugin probably needs some Mac customization. More investigation is needed.
#7 Updated by John Tull over 11 years ago
The new ability to change keyboard shortcuts provides a workaround to this problem. I would suggest that the defaults for OS X should be changed to meta+Letter, e.g., meta+v for add vector layer. Otherwise, we need to come up with a proper solution or this will create many problems for OS X users.
#8 Updated by William Kyngesburye about 11 years ago
Currently in Qgis 1.1.0 for me, when the GRASS shell is active, shortcuts are ignored. Though the menu still hilites briefly, which is distracting.
I would suggest, as John does, to not use plain keystrokes as shortcuts. This goes against OSX conventions (and guidelines?), and possibly Windows and Linux conventions as well. Since there appears to be some overlap in shortcuts vs. some that use platform standards or other meta keys (cmd-P for print, P for Properties), other modifier keys could also be used in combination with the platform meta (cmd-shift-P).
#11 Updated by William Kyngesburye about 11 years ago
OK, I found where the shortcuts are initially set in qgisapp.cpp.
I checked all the single-letter shortcuts and all but one can be changed to meta+shift+letter without conflicts. Layer->Show all layers would conflict with Save As. ...hmm, maybe U for unhide.
I'll do this later, if I don't hear any better suggestions.
#12 Updated by William Kyngesburye about 11 years ago
- Status changed from Feedback to Closed
- Resolution set to fixed
Applied in f269da46 (SVN r11390).
There was also an anomaly with the + and - keys (used in zoom in/out and add/remove all from overview). + only registers with shift=, so there is no distinction between ctrl+ and shift-ctrl+. So I removed the ctrl +/- shortcuts from the add/remove all from overview actions and used ctrl +/- for zooming.