Bug report #13174
Regression: Modeler issue with temp outputs under Windows
Status: | Closed | ||
---|---|---|---|
Priority: | Severe/Regression | ||
Assignee: | - | ||
Category: | Processing/Modeller | ||
Affected QGIS version: | 2.10.1 | Regression?: | No |
Operating System: | Windows | Easy fix?: | No |
Pull Request or Patch supplied: | No | Resolution: | |
Crashes QGIS or corrupts data: | No | Copied to github as #: | 21237 |
Description
Using the GDAL "Dissolve Polygons" in Processing and in a model in Ubuntu runs fine.
Using it under Windows under Processing works too.
Using it in a model under Windows creates some strange path problems:
GDAL command: cmd.exe /C ogr2ogr.exe C:\\Users\\BERNDV~1\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\1a5ff9aa24844ba08fdb3350c62b46e1\\OUTPUTLAYERALGGDALOGRDISSOLVEPOLYGONS2.shp :\\Users\\BERNDV~1\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\b6850e80399344a2992ef795a0ae3e98\\OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4.sh OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4 -dialect sqlite -sql "SELECT ST_Union(geometry),*, SUM(AW) AS sum_diss, MIN(AW) AS min_diss, MAX(AW) AS max_diss, AVG(AW) AS avg_diss FROM 'OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4' GROUP BY FLAECHE2" -explodecollections GDAL command output: FAILURE: Unable to open datasource `:\\Users\\BERNDV~1\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\b6850e80399344a2992ef795a0ae3e98\\OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4.sh' with the following drivers. -> OCI -> SOSI -> ESRI Shapefile ...
the same algo in Processing:
GDAL command: cmd.exe /C ogr2ogr.exe C:\\Users\\BERNDV~1\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\4b0e510c709e4e0a97402e9d7d4f4bd1\\OUTPUTLAYER.shp C:\\Users\\BERNDV~1\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\b6850e80399344a2992ef795a0ae3e98\\OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4.shp OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4 -dialect sqlite -sql "SELECT ST_Union(geometry),*, SUM(AW) AS sum_diss, MIN(AW) AS min_diss, MAX(AW) AS max_diss, AVG(AW) AS avg_diss FROM 'OUTPUTLAYERALGQGISFIELDCALCULATOR4' GROUP BY FLAECHE2" -explodecollections GDAL command output: layernames ignored in combination with -sql
From the output path, the first and the last letters are missing (C:\\ ... .sh p )
Maybe this also occurs with other algos.
Win7, OSGEO4W, fresh simple install 2.10 with processing 2.10.1
p.s. horrible wysiwig editor
Associated revisions
[processing] quote return string when returning uri in ogrConnectionString
Fixes #13174
History
#1 Updated by Jürgen Fischer over 9 years ago
- Assignee deleted (
Giovanni Manghi)
#2 Updated by Giovanni Manghi over 9 years ago
- Assignee set to Giovanni Manghi
#3 Updated by Giovanni Manghi over 9 years ago
- Status changed from Open to Feedback
Just tested on both Linux and Windows (osgeo4w, qgis 2.10, Processing 2.10) and works just fine.
Can you please attach sample data? thanks.
#4 Updated by Bernd Vogelgesang over 9 years ago
- File Dissolve_Polygons_Bug_Example.zip added
Hi Giovanni,
I attach a folder with the two necessary shape files and a model which works under Linux, and the other which doesn't under Windows. They might not perfectly be the same cause I had to remodel due to GRASS-differences, but critical part under Windows is the trimmed path, as far as I can see. Just retested, it's really like I posted over here.
#5 Updated by Giovanni Manghi over 9 years ago
- Status changed from Feedback to Open
- Operating System set to Windows
- Assignee deleted (
Giovanni Manghi) - Subject changed from Modeler: GDAL Dissolve with path problems in Windows to Modeler issue with temp outputs under Windows
Bernd Vogelgesang wrote:
Hi Giovanni,
I attach a folder with the two necessary shape files and a model which works under Linux, and the other which doesn't under Windows. They might not perfectly be the same cause I had to remodel due to GRASS-differences, but critical part under Windows is the trimmed path, as far as I can see. Just retested, it's really like I posted over here.
Hi Bernd,
it works for me under Windows, but only if I choose to save outputs not as temp files. If I leave the outputs spaces blank the resulting path to the Windows temp folder seems very long. So to make a counter test I choose to save manually outputs in the same folder where temp ones are created, and it fails.
Seems to me an issue with the Modeller or Processing/Core, not with the tool.
#6 Updated by Anita Graser over 9 years ago
- Priority changed from Normal to Severe/Regression
This seems to be a regression between Processing 2.9 and 2.10 where 2.10 fails to run models because it cannot find the intermediate results it produced in a previous step. The model runs perfectly in 2.9.
Bellow you can see an example to reproduce: just chain QGIS buffer and OGR dissolve and it fails because it's looking for a file :
\\Users\\agraser\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\7f77fa47bcec4799818d1f5ea41cc8a9\\OUTPUT.sh(without C: and .sh instead of .shp)
Algorithm dissolve starting... Prepare algorithm: QGISFIXEDDISTANCEBUFFER_1 Running Fixed distance buffer [1/2] Parameters: INPUT =C:/Users/agraser/Downloads/qgis_sample_data/shapefiles/popp.shp, DISTANCE =10000, SEGMENTS =5, DISSOLVE =True Converting outputs OK. Execution took 67.825 ms (1 outputs). Prepare algorithm: GDALOGRDISSOLVEPOLYGONS_1 Running Dissolve polygons [2/2] Parameters: INPUT_LAYER =C:\\Users\\agraser\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\7f77fa47bcec4799818d1f5ea41cc8a9\\OUTPUT.shp, GEOMETRY =geometry, FIELD =TYPE, MULTI =False, FIELDS =False, COUNT =False, AREA =False, STATS =False, STATSATT =TYPE, OPTIONS = GDAL command: cmd.exe /C ogr2ogr.exe C:\\Users\\agraser\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\a44629a1c1f34bc4bf9d26ed974f2bb6\\OUTPUTLAYERALGGDALOGRDISSOLVEPOLYGONS1.shp :\\Users\\agraser\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\7f77fa47bcec4799818d1f5ea41cc8a9\\OUTPUT.sh OUTPUT -dialect sqlite -sql "SELECT ST_Union(geometry),TYPE FROM 'OUTPUT' GROUP BY TYPE" -explodecollections GDAL command output: FAILURE: Unable to open datasource `:\\Users\\agraser\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\processing\\7f77fa47bcec4799818d1f5ea41cc8a9\\OUTPUT.sh' with the following drivers. -> ESRI Shapefile -> MapInfo File -> UK .NTF -> SDTS -> TIGER -> S57 -> DGN -> VRT -> REC -> Memory -> BNA -> CSV -> NAS -> GML -> GPX -> KML -> GeoJSON -> Interlis 1 -> Interlis 2 -> GMT -> GPKG -> SQLite -> ODBC -> WAsP -> PGeo -> MSSQLSpatial -> OGDI -> PostgreSQL -> MySQL -> PCIDSK -> OpenFileGDB -> XPlane -> AVCBin -> AVCE00 -> DXF -> Geoconcept -> GeoRSS -> GPSTrackMaker -> VFK -> PGDump -> OSM -> GPSBabel -> SUA -> OpenAir -> PDS -> WFS -> HTF -> AeronavFAA -> Geomedia -> EDIGEO -> GFT -> GME -> SVG -> CouchDB -> Idrisi -> ARCGEN -> SEGUKOOA -> SEGY -> XLS -> ODS -> XLSX -> ElasticSearch -> PDF -> Walk -> CartoDB -> SXF Converting outputs OK. Execution took 0.125 ms (1 outputs). Model processed ok. Executed 2 algorithms total Converting outputs Loading resulting layers
#7 Updated by Anita Graser over 9 years ago
- Subject changed from Modeler issue with temp outputs under Windows to Regression: Modeler issue with temp outputs under Windows
#8 Updated by Victor Olaya about 9 years ago
- Status changed from Open to Closed
Fixed in changeset 72af56d8a2f7088b9501efc60fd76df89e5acbb5.